A discussion on abortion and taking of lives

Abortion debate

This list of questions is not meant to be exhaustive, but it describes the issues of the following analysis. Suppose that we tried to estimate the seriousness of a crime of murder by appraising the value of the FLO of which the victim had been deprived. Whatever reasons we may have for preserving or protecting non sentient beings, these reasons do not refer to their own interests. Although, in the end, it may be difficult to claim that every human being is a person. This famous argument is due to Singer, Much can be said about this issue, but a simple answer will do for the purposes of this essay. Some reject the argument on grounds relating to personal identity , holding that the fetus is not the same entity as the adult into which it will develop, and thus that the fetus does not have a "future like ours" in the required sense. Thus, an analogy with animals supports the thesis that abortion is wrong. Some aspects of the psychological sector for example, the ability to feel and perceive can be ascribed to the fetus but not to the embryo, conceptus, or the unicellular zygote. However, there are some basic rights of the pregnant woman, for example, the right of self-determination, the right of privacy, the right of physical integrity, and the right to live. The killing of fetuses is prohibited. Formerly the Catholic Church maintained that the first movement of the fetus shows that it is the breathing of life into the human body animation which separates the human fetus from animals. Second, the second premise could also be questioned since it is not at all clear whether fetuses are human beings in the sense of being persons, although they are of course human beings in the sense of being members of the species of homo sapiens. That is because people think that the second order reasons are weaker than the reasons of the first group. Because the case of pregnancy is like the case of the violinist, one is no more morally obligated to remain attached to a fetus than to remain attached to the violinist.

Rape It would be cruel and callous to force the pregnant woman who had been raped to give birth to a child. In both cases the fetus may be aborted or not.

The comatose patient objection claims that as patients in a reversible coma do not satisfy Warren's or some other criteria—they are not conscious, do not communicate, and so on—therefore they would lack a right to life on her view.

good questions to ask in abortion debate

Abortion is a safe medical procedure. John Noonan proposes the scenario of a family who was found to be liable for frostbite finger loss suffered by a dinner guest whom they refused to allow to stay overnight, although it was very cold outside and the guest showed signs of being sick.

Many have lifelong regrets afterward. The thought is that all forms of human life, including the fetus, are inherently valuable because they are connected to our thoughts on family and parenthood, among other natural aspects of humanity. Consider their moral-relevance problem. For these reasons, they argue that the conservative view should be rejected. There was a class of infants who had futures that included a class of events that were identical to the futures of the readers of this essay. Thomson draws our attention to the fact that in a pregnancy, although a fetus uses a woman's body as a life-support system, a pregnant woman does not use a fetus's body as a life-support system. Warren agrees that infants are non-persons and so killing them is not strictly murder , but denies that infanticide is generally permissible. What can be said of her decision? Notice how nicely the FLO account of the wrongness of killing explains this unanimity of opinion.

But, even if the fetus is a human life form, it does not necessarily follow that it should be protected by that fact, simpliciter. The Worst of Crimes Argument The FLO account of the wrongness of killing is correct because it explains why we believe that killing is one of the worst of crimes. One reason for these exceptions is to eliminate from consideration cases whose ethical analysis should be controversial detailed for clear-headed opponents of abortion.

Notice how nicely the FLO account of the wrongness of killing explains this unanimity of opinion.

reasons for abortion

The violinist, who suffers from a rare blood disease, will die if disconnected. As this response makes clear, Marquis's argument requires that what will later have valuable experiences and activities is the same entity, the same biological organism, as the embryo.

Is abortion morally acceptable when the woman?s life is not in danger due to the pregnancy?

Therefore, no true Kantian would treat persons as she would treat animals. I still have feelings for her and for me to have a child with her would have been a beautiful thing. Should they be respected or be refused? Potential life should not be more valued then actual life. First Order Reasons vs. The embryo is an innocent human being. Since the latter argument is convincing, the former argument should be also. This can also be seen according to the notion person. The loss of a future biological life does not explain the misfortune of death. The purpose of this essay is to set out an argument the claim that abortion, except perhaps in instances, is seriously wrong. According to their view, it is only plausible to argue that an abortion is morally reprehensible if the people in a given society do have a common interest not to abort and make a moral agreement which is enforced by law. On the other hand, there exists a local relativity according to the availability of medical supplies in and within countries which determines whether the life of a premature infant will be saved. If "personhood" is acquired, opinions differ about when this happens. Grounding the right to life in essential natural capacities rather than accidental developed capacities is said to have several advantages.

Gaye decided she could not continue with the pregnancy and so, at 22 weeks, her labour was induced in Belfast because she could not be offered the same medical treatment km away at home in Dublin. Contractarians have tried to deal with their scope problems by arguing that duties to some individuals who are not persons can be justified even though those individuals are not contracting members of the moral community.

why is abortion illegal

Thomson takes it that you may permissibly unplug yourself from the violinist even though this will kill him.

Thus, an analogy with animals supports the thesis that abortion is wrong.

A discussion on abortion and taking of lives

The great wrong to the victim explains the brutalization, not the other way around. How would one go about doing this? The extreme conservative proponents argue that biological development from the fetus to a human being is an incremental process which leaves no room for a morally significant break liberals deny this line of thinking. To claim that a fetus has an FLO is to claim that a fetus now has the potential to be in a state of a certain kind in the future. Like any other difficult situation, abortion creates stress. For example, people with severe mental handicaps or disorder seem not to have personhood. For many who face a crisis pregnancy there are husbands, boyfriends, fathers, brothers and grandfathers who support them. To have an abortion would be, by definition, homicide. One should always try to find better ways to cope with hard ethical problems. Disabled fetuses may be aborted like other fetuses, disabled adult human persons have to be respected like other people. This list of questions is not meant to be exhaustive, but it describes the issues of the following analysis. Steinbock , p. Based on whether brain activity in the brain stem , or just in the cerebral cortex , is relevant for personhood, two concepts of "brain birth" emerge: [10] at the first appearance of brain waves in lower brain brain stem - 6—8 weeks of gestation paralleling "whole brain death" at the first appearance of brain waves in higher brain cerebral cortex - weeks of gestation paralleling "higher brain death" [11] These writers disagree on precisely which features confer a right to life, [12] but agree those features must be certain developed psychological or physiological features which the embryo lacks. According to a global study collaboratively conducted by the World Health Organization and the Guttmacher Institute , most unsafe abortions occur where abortion is illegal. In these terms, once the humanity of the fetus is perceived, abortion is never right except in self-defense.
Rated 9/10 based on 17 review
Positions for and Against Abortion